
The sign outside the Harry S Truman Building, State Department headquarters in Washington. Photo G. Edward Johnson / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0)
The State Department has called the ratification of the Turkey-Libya memorandum "unhelpful and provocative" and said Washington's position "has not changed," a sharper answer that came on Sunday, October 25, four days after a lukewarm first response. The shift followed a push by Greece's embassy in Washington, the Hellenic American Leadership Council (HALC), allies in Congress and American Jewish organizations.
Edited by the Hellenic Daily News newsroom
The new wording
"The announcement of the ratification of the Turkish-Libyan delimitation memorandum of understanding has raised tensions in the region and is unhelpful and provocative — and our position on this matter has not changed," a State Department spokesperson told Kathimerini.
The spokesperson went on to urge all countries, including partners in the Eastern Mediterranean, "to resolve maritime disputes through good-faith negotiations and avoid any provocative behavior." The statement noted that Greece and Turkey are both NATO allies and encouraged them to talk bilaterally, adding that the peaceful resolution of such disputes "opens the way for commercial investment and exploration that will benefit the entire region."
What happened on October 21
Libya's House of Representatives, based in the eastern city of Benghazi, unanimously ratified the 2019 memorandum on Tuesday, October 20. When Kathimerini asked for a reaction the next day, the State Department offered only a general call for "good-faith negotiation" and bilateral talks between Athens and Ankara. It said nothing about the deal itself.
That answer caused dissatisfaction and concern in Athens, Kathimerini reported. The worry was that Turkey and the Tripoli government could read Washington's silence as tacit acceptance of their maritime claims. It also stood out because the European Union had just gone much further. On October 21, with the backing of all 27 member states, the EU said the memorandum was "null and void and cannot produce any legal consequences for third States."
The Greek American campaign
According to Kathimerini, the Greek Embassy in Washington then worked with HALC, its allies on Capitol Hill and American Jewish organizations to get the department to clarify its stance. Kathimerini did not name the lawmakers or the groups involved.
HALC took its case to Secretary of State Marco Rubio in an open letter that supporters can sign online. The letter says the department's October 21 response "said only that it encourages partners to 'resolve maritime disputes through good-faith negotiation'" and that Greece and Turkey should talk bilaterally. "That is weaker than the position the Department took when the memorandum was first signed." It warns that if Washington declines to address the legal question, "Ankara and Tripoli will take this silence as tacit acceptance of their illegal and revisionist actions."
The group asked Rubio to state publicly that the memorandum cannot create legal rights or obligations for third countries such as Greece, to affirm Greece's sovereign rights including the maritime zones generated by its islands, to make clear that unilateral claims will not be allowed to interfere with lawful exploration by American companies, and to coordinate a common position with the EU and regional partners. "The U.S. position should be at least as clear as Europe's," the letter concludes.
Why HALC says American interests are at stake
HALC framed the issue as an American one, too. Its letter says Chevron signed leases in February to operate four offshore blocks in Greece, including South Crete 1 and South Crete 2, and that Turkey's Defense Ministry has claimed those blocks overlap with the zone the memorandum assigns to Libya. It adds that ExxonMobil holds exploration rights in two blocks west and southwest of Crete. The letter also points to Naval Support Activity Souda Bay on Crete, which it calls one of the most important U.S. and NATO facilities in the Eastern Mediterranean.
Back to the language of 2019
"Unhelpful and provocative" is not new. The State Department used the same words in December 2019, shortly after Turkey and the Tripoli government signed the memorandum. In January 2020, it acknowledged Greece's overlapping maritime claims and said that, under the Law of the Sea, islands are generally entitled to an exclusive economic zone and continental shelf. In June 2020, Francis Fannon, then Assistant Secretary of State for Energy Resources, said the memorandum "cannot as a legal matter affect the rights or obligations of third states."
Sunday's statement brings back the 2019 wording, but it does not repeat the explicit legal point about third countries that HALC asked for. The line that the U.S. position "has not changed" does, however, point back to those earlier statements.
What comes next
Greece calls the memorandum "illegal, null and void" because it ignores Crete and other Greek islands. The EU and Egypt share that view, and HALC says Israel has also rejected the deal. Egypt's Foreign Minister Badr Abdelatty restated Cairo's opposition to the ratification in talks with Turkish Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan in Istanbul on October 23.
For Greek Americans, the change in tone within four days is a sign that advocacy in Washington can still move the needle. HALC's next ask is a clear U.S. statement that the memorandum does not bind Greece.
Read also






















